Cognitive Walkthrough Grading Criteria – CS485/CS585


Points will be awarded on the following criteria

1. Description of Personas. 25pts

Based on observations of real users? Why or why not?

2. Description of interface design 25pts.

Does the description focus on the interface issues that need to be evaluated?

3. Description of tasks. 25 pts.

Are the tasks realistic and detailed? Do they address the interface issues?

4. Scenario walkthrough 25 pts.

Are the user’s assumptions well articulated at each step of the scenario? Is the story believable?

5. Conceptual model. Extra credit (25 pts).

Has a coherent model been articulated that unifies the design?